The Crow (2024)

RATING: 0/10

The 2024 remake of The Crow, starring Bill Skarsgård, falls flat in its attempt to recapture the gothic magic of the original. Despite some impressive visuals, the film suffers from poor writing, a lackluster love story, and performances that fail to live up to the emotional weight carried by the original. With convoluted storytelling, especially around the introduction of the Skull Cowboy character, the remake struggles to justify its existence.

Synopsis:In The Crow (2024), Bill Skarsgård steps into the role of Eric Draven, a man brutally murdered along with his fiancée. After being resurrected by the mystical powers of the crow, Eric is given the chance to seek vengeance on those responsible for their deaths. However, unlike the streamlined narrative of the 1994 original, this remake introduces a more complicated lore, including the character of the Skull Cowboy, who serves as a guide of sorts, explaining Draven's powers and purpose. The film attempts to weave a tale of love and revenge, but it fails to capture the raw emotion and tight pacing that made its predecessor a cult classic.

In-depth Review:

Acting: Skarsgård’s Missed Opportunity

Bill Skarsgård, known for his strong, eerie performances (particularly in It as Pennywise), seems like a fitting choice to take on the role of the tortured Eric Draven. However, while he brings his characteristic intensity, his portrayal lacks the emotional vulnerability that made Brandon Lee’s version of the character so unforgettable. Lee’s Eric was driven by love, heartbreak, and rage, with a balance of sorrow and fury that resonated deeply. Skarsgård’s Draven, on the other hand, feels more detached, as if he’s going through the motions without fully conveying the character’s internal torment.

The supporting cast does little to elevate the film either. The love story between Eric and his fiancée, which takes up the first 40 minutes of the movie, feels forced and artificial. Unlike the deeply affecting and tragically romantic relationship between Eric and Shelly in the 1994 film, this version never achieves the same emotional depth. The chemistry between Skarsgård and his co-star is weak, and the script does little to make their connection feel genuine. Without this strong emotional core, Eric’s quest for vengeance feels hollow and unmotivated.

Cinematography: Visually Impressive but Lacking Substance

The cinematography in The Crow (2024) is, at times, striking. The film captures a dark, atmospheric cityscape that is visually reminiscent of the original. The use of shadows, rain, and urban decay creates a gothic, moody aesthetic that complements the film’s themes of death and resurrection. However, despite these visual achievements, the cinematography lacks the haunting, ethereal quality that elevated the 1994 film.

In the original, every frame was filled with an almost poetic sadness, a reflection of Eric’s grief and the loss that haunted the story. Here, the visuals feel more polished but less emotionally resonant. The film seems more concerned with looking stylish than with conveying the deeper emotional undercurrents of the story. The camera lingers on action sequences and flashy set pieces, but fails to immerse the viewer in the melancholic beauty that made The Crow so iconic.

Story: Convoluted and Disjointed

One of the film’s most glaring weaknesses is its storytelling. While the original The Crow thrived on its simplicity—focusing on a straightforward revenge arc fueled by love and loss—this remake introduces convoluted lore that muddies the narrative. The inclusion of the Skull Cowboy, who is positioned as the entity that grants Eric his resurrection and powers, feels like a clumsy addition. His role in the story is poorly explained, and his interactions with Eric are confusing at best, undermining the mythic quality of the crow as the supernatural force guiding Eric on his path.

Instead of building on the emotional and symbolic power of the original story, the Skull Cowboy introduces an unnecessary layer of complexity. His presence distracts from the core narrative and leaves the audience questioning his true purpose. Is he a guide? A gatekeeper? The film never makes this clear, and as a result, the audience is left confused about the mechanics of Eric’s resurrection. This muddled plot device comes across as poor writing, detracting from the emotional weight of Eric’s journey and making the film feel disjointed.

Moreover, the first 40 minutes of the film are spent trying to establish a romantic relationship between Eric and his fiancée, but it pales in comparison to the original. In the 1994 version, the love story between Eric and Shelly was the heart of the movie—a love so strong it defied death. Here, the relationship feels rushed, with little screen time devoted to developing any meaningful connection between the characters. Without a believable love story, Eric’s quest for vengeance lacks the emotional drive that should propel the film forward.

Final Thoughts: A Convoluted and Soulless Remake

The 2024 remake of The Crow is a disappointing reimagining of a beloved cult classic. While Bill Skarsgård brings intensity to the role of Eric Draven, his performance lacks the emotional depth necessary to carry the film. The cinematography, though visually appealing, never quite matches the atmospheric brilliance of the original, and the story suffers from convoluted writing, particularly with the poorly executed addition of the Skull Cowboy.

The love story at the heart of the film is far less believable than its predecessor, leaving the audience emotionally disconnected from Eric’s journey. What should have been a poetic tale of love and vengeance is instead a muddled, disjointed film that never fully justifies its existence. Fans of the original The Crow will likely be disappointed by this lackluster remake, which, despite its polished surface, is ultimately hollow and devoid of the emotional resonance that made the 1994 version a classic.

---

-Written by

 Timothy Gaer

Director